Although Molly and Jon didn't attend the same high school, they first met back in 1998 during their freshman year. They met through mutual friends, probably; neither can recall the time or place. What they can remember is that they had crushes on each other that lasted for...approximately two weeks.
Fast forward to a very early morning on a crowded New York City uptown 6 train in the fall of 2010 where they happened to run into each other. Within 24 hours a plan was hatched to work on a record together and, within that year, they recorded an album and reconnected as friends. It wasn't until the end of the summer of 2011 that the sparks finally flew.
Fast forward again to foggy day in Hanalei Bay, Kauai on July 29, 2013. As Molly swam obliviously in the ocean, Jon managed to sneak her great-grandmother's wedding ring out into the water and popped the question right there in the waves!